Finally a priest calls out the fantasy writings of J.R.R. Tolkien for what they truly are - not Catholic.
The priest asks a simple question.
If the writings of J.R.R. Tolkien are truly Catholic then where are the conversions?
Answer: There are no conversions
The works of Tolkien are pure gnosticism.
They are not channels of Grace!
Shea is having a fit - all these years he has been labeling those who attend Latin Mass as Gnostics
Now along comes a rad trad priest who warns against the evils of the works of Tolkien see here
The lover of Star Wars, Star Trek & the Lord of The Rings complains:
Reactionary Catholics Warn of the Evils of J.R.R. Tolkien February 5, 2014 By Mark Shea 32 Comments You knew it had to happen. In the ever purging and purifying world of uber-super-pure Reactionary Catholicism, the Lidless Eye has finally turned its gaze upon Tolkien and found him to be Not Really Catholic. Rorate Coeli run the demented analysis and then passive-aggressively takes it’s hand off the piece with one of those lame “I’m just sayin’” disclaimers by which passive-aggressive weenies attack people while trying to wash their hands of responsibility. I particularly like the way Charles Manson and drug abuse somehow get dragged into this Kitchen Sink Plus “analysis”.I always hated the LOTR its about time someone says something.
The LOTR is a sacred cow for Shea and his ilk.